A hall of famer Dominates the league their whole career, they dont have one great season followed by a handful of solid seasons. A hall of famer is rarely stopped by another team all together if they face a great team perhaps they are contained but nothing more. Examples of what I am talking about Kurt Warner - In my opinion not HOF Tom Brady and Peyton Manning - Yes Anotonio Gates and Tony Gongzales - Yes Jason Witten and Dallas Clark - No Ray Lewis and Brian Urlacher - Yes AJ Hawk and Teddy Bruschi?????- NO! Shaun Alaexander and Edgerinn James - Close but no Cigar Ladanian Tomlinson- Yes Charles Woodson and Champ Bailey - Yes Ronde Barber - No The way I see it people are confusing good for a few seasons with Greatness. I just wanted everyone elses take on this. Like I said I know its off topic but I found it interesting that the medias standards have gotten to this level.