What if we had brought in Jim Harbaugh in 2011?

Discussion in 'Chargers Fan Forum' started by JohnnyX, Jan 20, 2013.

  1. JohnnyX Well-Known Member

    Member Since:
    Oct 7, 2010
    Message Count:
    1,334
    Location:
    San Diego
    Ratings Received:
    +85 / 7 / -5
    *Assuming we fired Norv in 2011 instead of year later.

    Do you think our team would be in the same place the 49ers currently are?

    I think we might have although it's hard to say and really just speculation at this point. Still the Harbaugh led teams had guts and heart and don't give up. Something we haven't seen from Norv and this team.
    • Winner Winner x 1
    • Informative Informative x 1
    • HollywoodLeo Well-Known Member

      Member Since:
      Mar 13, 2006
      Message Count:
      13,024
      Ratings Received:
      +1,252 / 23 / -0
      What if LT, Gates, and Rivers never got hurt in the 2007 playoffs?

      What if I got a better high paying job?

      What if I hit the Power Ball?

      What if we quit looking at the past, which is a loser's mentality?
      • Agree Agree x 3
      • Like Like x 2
      • Disagree Disagree x 1
      • Winner Winner x 1
      • Bolts4lyfe BoltTalker

        Member Since:
        Mar 25, 2012
        Message Count:
        1,778
        Location:
        Prescott, Arizona
        Ratings Received:
        +445 / 15 / -1
        Stop! just Stop!

        Look at their team

        Joe Staley, Mike Iupati, Anthony Davis, Alex Boone, Jonathan Goodwin

        Carlos Rodgers, Patrick Willis, Navarro Bowman, Justin Smith, Tarrel Brown, Aldon Smith, Ahmad Brooks, Dashon Goldson, Donte Whitner

        Frank Gore, Vernon Davis, Michael Crabtree, Delanie Walker

        Should I keep going????????
      • Blue Bolt Persona Non Grata

        Member Since:
        Oct 28, 2009
        Message Count:
        14,487
        Ratings Received:
        +1,853 / 32 / -19
      • Bolts4lyfe BoltTalker

        Member Since:
        Mar 25, 2012
        Message Count:
        1,778
        Location:
        Prescott, Arizona
        Ratings Received:
        +445 / 15 / -1
        Its called using your off season Wisely bringing in or re signing free agents, drafting

        They had almost a top 10 pick since 2005, most of them were multiple first round picks. If you were to tell me we drafted Vernon Davis and Joe Staley in the same draft I think I'd mess myself with excitement
        • Article Writer

        Concudan Caffeinated Commando

        Member Since:
        Mar 5, 2006
        Message Count:
        43,484
        Location:
        North side of So Cal
        Ratings Received:
        +2,940 / 21 / -1
        Jimmy Boy Harbaugh made one of the guttsyest calls switching to Kappyburah this year. That said, the 9'ers team has been rebuilding over the last 5 years. Harbaugh did not walk in, sprinkle magical harbaugh dust and suddenly the team was good.

        If he came in in 2011 there is a good chance we would be right where we are now, because the roster would probably be the same. What if they had named the team the San Diego Grunions in the 60's instead of the Chargers? Or what if we had drafted....

        We didnt, and the wayback machine only works in cartoons.
      • CoronaDoug Hipsters Suck

        Member Since:
        Feb 14, 2007
        Message Count:
        7,350
        Location:
        D F W
        Ratings Received:
        +751 / 10 / -2
        What if your girlfriend on your signature banner made some playoff FG's?
        • Winner Winner x 1
        • Ikeman83 Werter Pöbel

          Member Since:
          Feb 3, 2012
          Message Count:
          2,393
          Location:
          Flensburg, Germany
          Ratings Received:
          +608 / 37 / -7

          How many of those players have they acquired since Harbaugh became the HC? Keep in mind that their roster is currently burdened by 8 mil in dead cap space from their b/u QB, too.
        • Bolts4lyfe BoltTalker

          Member Since:
          Mar 25, 2012
          Message Count:
          1,778
          Location:
          Prescott, Arizona
          Ratings Received:
          +445 / 15 / -1
          Thats my point! They have one of the best O lines, One of the best fron 7's, one of the best secondary's, Vernon Davis, Frank Gore

          I give him credit on Kaepernick though

          It appears Jim Harbaugh was given the same key to a very different car that was handed to Norv, it seems JH knows how to drive

          I applaud Jim Harbaugh and everything he's done for that organization. But I would give 100% of the credit to him leading this team to a super bowl if he were able to do it with lesser talent.

          I mean his number 2 RB and TE Kendall Hunter and Delanie Walker would be number one's at their position on almost certainly any other team
        • HEXEDBOLT Well-Known Member

          Member Since:
          Jul 11, 2006
          Message Count:
          11,518
          Ratings Received:
          +1,209 / 35 / -3
          If I didn't move to North Carolina in 1999, I probably would still be living in San Diego.
          • Article Writer

          Concudan Caffeinated Commando

          Member Since:
          Mar 5, 2006
          Message Count:
          43,484
          Location:
          North side of So Cal
          Ratings Received:
          +2,940 / 21 / -1
          Who knows, maybe we woulda shipped you off to a gulag in Sibera for grumpiness above and beyond...;)
        • Ikeman83 Werter Pöbel

          Member Since:
          Feb 3, 2012
          Message Count:
          2,393
          Location:
          Flensburg, Germany
          Ratings Received:
          +608 / 37 / -7
          Norv was given what was probably the greatest roster for a new HC ever in 2007. Harbaugh took over a pretty talented roster that was being wasted and turned it instantly into a powerhouse. I wouldn't say that the cars were that different.
          • Agree Agree x 1
          • Carlsbad_Bolt_Fan Well-Known Member

            Member Since:
            Jun 25, 2006
            Message Count:
            6,070
            Ratings Received:
            +1,069 / 10 / -4
            And if I had the winning numbers in Friday's lotto, I would have won $60 million! :roflmao:
          • Joy Division Slightly-known Member

            Member Since:
            Jun 30, 2008
            Message Count:
            879
            Location:
            NorCal
            Ratings Received:
            +271 / 2 / -0
            What if we had brought in Belichik? Or Coughlin? Or Sean Payton? Or McCarthy? Or....
          • HEXEDBOLT Well-Known Member

            Member Since:
            Jul 11, 2006
            Message Count:
            11,518
            Ratings Received:
            +1,209 / 35 / -3
            Before or after tilting back a few?????
            • Article Writer

            Concudan Caffeinated Commando

            Member Since:
            Mar 5, 2006
            Message Count:
            43,484
            Location:
            North side of So Cal
            Ratings Received:
            +2,940 / 21 / -1
            While. And once over Russian air space it would have to be vodka per international treaty...
          • JohnnyX Well-Known Member

            Member Since:
            Oct 7, 2010
            Message Count:
            1,334
            Location:
            San Diego
            Ratings Received:
            +85 / 7 / -5
            I didn't make this thread as to have a discussion of 'What if's'. I was hoping if there was any real correlation between a good coach and a NORV type coach and how that could have possible changed our fortune this last season.


            @HollywoodLeo

            Looking at the past is certainty not a loser mentality. The only way a coach can access a team is to look back and wonder "What if". Sure we fans can't do much about it but can't tell me had we had a better coach we'd be having more success.
            • Agree Agree x 1
            • HEXEDBOLT Well-Known Member

              Member Since:
              Jul 11, 2006
              Message Count:
              11,518
              Ratings Received:
              +1,209 / 35 / -3
              They make good food in Russia don't they, like Carne Asadaski?
            • HollywoodLeo Well-Known Member

              Member Since:
              Mar 13, 2006
              Message Count:
              13,024
              Ratings Received:
              +1,252 / 23 / -0
              There is a whole world of difference between a coach who is actually involved in shaping the team looking at the past of his team and other examples from other teams as a way to shape his team's future and some fan playing the "what if" game regarding what we could have done two years ago.
            • Savage Lizard Charger fan at 7000'

              Member Since:
              Jul 12, 2007
              Message Count:
              3,680
              Location:
              Big Bear Lake, CA
              Ratings Received:
              +780 / 21 / -1
              I don't know, Raider fans are always jumping into it.
            • Joy Division Slightly-known Member

              Member Since:
              Jun 30, 2008
              Message Count:
              879
              Location:
              NorCal
              Ratings Received:
              +271 / 2 / -0
              What if we throw the season and get first overall pick next year?;)
              Oh wait, disregard this post it deals in a hypothetical. Carry on...
            • BoltWalt Well-Known Member

              Member Since:
              Aug 23, 2009
              Message Count:
              227
              Location:
              San Diego (City Heights)
              Ratings Received:
              +45 / 1 / -0
              I believe the Bolts would have been far better off with Harbaugh as Head Coach, perhaps even a playoff team both years only if they had replaced A.J. Smith at the same time. I liked how he turned USD into a winning program, and watched how he continue his rise as a great head coach at Stanford and I hoped the Bolts had been watching from the time he was at USD, but of course it turned into a missed opportunity.
              • Informative Informative x 1

              Share This Page